Photo Credit: Getty Images
In an unexpected twist following the release of Martha Stewart's Netflix documentary, New York Post columnist Andrea Peyser has forcefully responded to Stewart's on-camera claim of her demise. The incident, which unfolded in the October 30 release of "Martha," highlights lingering tensions from Stewart's 2004 legal troubles.
During a segment discussing her conviction for lying to FBI investigators, Stewart referenced Peyser, whom she called "New York Post lady," stating she was "dead now, thank goodness." The lifestyle mogul's comments stemmed from Peyser's extensive coverage of her insider trading trial, which resulted in Stewart serving five months at West Virginia's Alderson Federal Prison Camp.
Peyser, who has been with the New York Post since 1989, responded with characteristic sharp wit in her latest column: "I'm alive, bitch!" The veteran journalist, who continues to actively publish with eight bylines in 2024 alone, expressed more sadness than anger at Stewart's remarks, noting she was "overwhelmingly sad in the face of Martha's bitterness."
The documentary reveals previously undisclosed details about Stewart's prison experience, including her first-day ordeal. "I had to do all that crap that you see in the movies," Stewart recounted, describing the intake process through letters she wrote during her incarceration. The emotional impact of her conviction was particularly evident in her daughter Alexis's reaction, who "fainted when they read the verdict," according to Stewart.
Before this recent controversy, Stewart's relationship with the press during her trial had been notably tense. Court records from 2004 show Stewart's legal team frequently criticized media coverage, particularly the New York Post's reporting. The publication maintained its aggressive coverage throughout the proceedings, with Peyser's columns drawing particular attention for their critical stance.
The incident has sparked renewed discussion about the long-term impact of Stewart's conviction and subsequent imprisonment. Industry analysts note that despite the legal setback, Stewart successfully rebuilt her empire, though certain media relationships clearly remain fraught. Financial reports indicate her brand has maintained significant market presence, with the Netflix documentary serving as the latest extension of her public rehabilitation.
The documentary, while comprehensive in its coverage of Stewart's life and career, has generated additional controversies beyond the Peyser incident, including Stewart's candid discussions about her marriage and time in prison. Netflix representatives have not commented on the factual discrepancy regarding Peyser's status.
