Photo Credit: Getty Images
In a case that underscores the complexities of corporate pension rights, JPMorgan Chase has denied a $331 monthly pension payout to Elaine Silverberg, the widow of a former Chase Manhattan Bank employee who died unexpectedly in 1988. The dispute, which has stretched over 13 years, centers around missing paperwork from an era predating major pension reform.
Melvyn Silverberg worked as a systems analyst at Chase Manhattan Bank for a decade until 1979, accumulating a pension pot now valued at approximately $53,000. His untimely death at age 43 from multiple organ failure left his wife Elaine, then 37, to raise their three children alone. Despite confirmation from the Social Security Administration regarding the pension's monthly value, JPMorgan Chase maintains its position on withholding payment.
The legal framework surrounding this case hinges on the Retirement Equity Act of 1984, enacted during the Reagan administration to protect spousal benefits. However, since Silverberg left Chase before this legislation and allegedly didn't complete spousal benefit election forms, the bank claims it cannot release the funds. Christopher Dagg, senior staff attorney at the Mid-Atlantic Pension Counseling Project, characterized the bank's stance as "weak," noting a recurring pattern in pension disputes where plans shift burden of proof onto participants.
Political intervention has yielded no results. Former New York Congressman Eliot Engel advocated for Silverberg in 2017, stating in official correspondence that "Mrs. Silverberg was informed by several employees at Chase she qualified for her spouse's pension on many occasions." Senator Cory Booker (D-NJ) also attempted to intervene on her behalf.
The case has drawn criticism from former Chase employees. Elazer Lew, Melvyn's former colleague, expressed outrage at the bank's treatment of the widow. Meanwhile, JPMorgan Chase, which reported third-quarter profits exceeding $12 billion, maintains its position. "While we sympathize with Mrs. Silverberg, she is asking us to pay without necessary documentation," a bank spokesperson stated.
This dispute highlights broader issues in pension administration and corporate responsibility. As Elaine Silverberg, now 73, notes, "I am not destitute, but this was never an issue about poverty — only justice." Unable to afford high-powered legal representation, she continues her fight against one of Wall Street's most powerful institutions, hoping CEO Jamie Dimon will intervene to resolve the matter.
