Photo Credit: Getty Images
After reprising his iconic role as Spider-Man in the successful Spider-Man: No Way Home (2021), Tobey Maguire is reportedly considering another comeback in the upcoming Spider-Man 4—but only if the price is right. Sources close to Maguire confirm that the actor, now 49, is negotiating a substantial payday, pushing for compensation on par with Hollywood’s top-earning actors, including Tom Cruise. This “giant check” demand underscores the value Maguire places on the franchise that cemented his Hollywood legacy and substantially contributed to his wealth over the past two decades.
Maguire’s return to the Spider-Verse marked one of the most celebrated aspects of No Way Home, which also saw Andrew Garfield and Tom Holland teaming up to deliver a multiverse storyline that thrilled audiences and brought in record profits. In light of this success, Maguire feels he’s in a strong position to leverage his market appeal, especially as fans push for the original Spider-Man’s continued presence in the Marvel universe. His advisors, many of whom have been with him throughout his career, support this tough negotiation stance, reportedly encouraging him to use his “poker skills” to ensure he doesn’t “leave money on the table”.
While Holland and Zendaya are already confirmed to return, the negotiations with Maguire and Garfield remain unofficial. Garfield has shown enthusiasm for another role, but Maguire’s demands have become a defining factor. Should Marvel Studios agree to Maguire’s terms, the beloved actor may once again swing into the spotlight. For fans, the possibility of seeing the three Spider-Men on-screen again could make Spider-Man 4 one of the franchise’s most anticipated projects to date.
This high-stakes approach shows Maguire’s careful consideration of the role that he’s defined and aims to secure substantial recognition for his contributions to the superhero genre.
